Righteousness Aura + Monstrous Upheaval
Posted: Thu May 10, 2012 3:13 pm
This is a general question about parsing the card's text:
Righteousness Aura Says:
If a hero or ally in your party would deal damage, it deals that much +1 instead.
Monstrous Upheaval Says:
Your hero deals 2 melee damage to target hero or ally for each Monster hero and ally you control.
If I have 4 monsters in play, does MU deal 2 damage four times or it deals 8 damage once. The sentence can be parsed both ways:
[ Your hero deals 2 melee damage to target hero or ally ] for [ each Monster hero and ally you control. ]
or
Your hero deals [ 2 melee damage to target hero or ally for each Monster hero and ally you control. ]
In the first case, the damage done with the aura would be 12. In the second case it would be 9. Also, if the second case holds, then it could be made much clearer by stating it like this:
Your hero deals melee damage to target hero or ally equal to the number of Monster hero or allies you control times 2.
Righteousness Aura Says:
If a hero or ally in your party would deal damage, it deals that much +1 instead.
Monstrous Upheaval Says:
Your hero deals 2 melee damage to target hero or ally for each Monster hero and ally you control.
If I have 4 monsters in play, does MU deal 2 damage four times or it deals 8 damage once. The sentence can be parsed both ways:
[ Your hero deals 2 melee damage to target hero or ally ] for [ each Monster hero and ally you control. ]
or
Your hero deals [ 2 melee damage to target hero or ally for each Monster hero and ally you control. ]
In the first case, the damage done with the aura would be 12. In the second case it would be 9. Also, if the second case holds, then it could be made much clearer by stating it like this:
Your hero deals melee damage to target hero or ally equal to the number of Monster hero or allies you control times 2.